Chat with us, powered by LiveChat
automq vs apache kafka

10x Cost Savings and Instant Elasticity

Cut Kafka cloud bill
Reduce Kafka Cloud Costs by up to 90%
Solve all Kafka's pain points
Resolve Kafka's Operational Challenges
Better performance than kafka
Enterprise-Grade Kafka Performance
Difficult to scale in/out

Difficult to Scale In/Out

Scaling Kafka in or out requires the manual creation of partition migration strategies and replication of partition data. This process is not only high-risk and resource-intensive but also time-consuming.

Expensive

Expensive

Computation and storage are tightly coupled in Kafka, meaning they must be scaled in or out simultaneously. This coupling often results in resource wastage. Additionally, to guarantee low latency and high throughput, users often incur significant storage expenses.

Weak Self-healing ability

Weak Self-Healing Ability

Kafka cannot self-heal from abnormal states such as data hotspots and uneven capacity.

Data Skew

Data Skew

Kafka cannot automatically rectify scenarios involving data skew and hotspot partitions, leading to performance degradation and operational inefficiencies.

Disk read performance is poor

Disk Read Limitations

Reading historical data in Apache Kafka can severely impact write performance due to Page Cache pollution. This degradation not only affects Kafka itself but also propagates issues to upstream and downstream systems.

Low capacity utilization

Inefficient Resource Usage

Kafka’s tightly coupled storage and computation model lacks elasticity. Users must often over-provision to meet peak demands, resulting in significant resource wastage. Moreover, data skew and uneven traffic can lead to further inefficiencies and underutilized resources within the cluster.

AutoMQ - Swift Autoscaling

AutoMQ can seamlessly auto-scale within seconds, providing a secure and efficient scaling experience for Apache Kafka. This capability is primarily enabled by the following innovative enhancements by AutoMQ:

AutoMQ - 10x Cheaper than Apache Kafka

AutoMQ leverages an advanced streaming storage engine that significantly reduces costs across multiple dimensions, including computing, storage, and operations when compared to Apache Kafka. The integrated Self-Balancing component ensures automatic cluster capacity balancing, maximizing the utilization of the entire cluster.

AutoMQ - Self-Healing Capabilities

AutoMQ leverages an advanced cloud-first shared storage architecture to deliver continuous Self-Balancing capabilities. This innovative system autonomously self-heals from anomalies such as compute instance crashes, data hotspots, and unbalanced traffic. Unlike traditional Kafka, AutoMQ provides automated reliability and efficiency, significantly reducing operational complexities and enhancing performance and scalability.

AutoMQ possesses self-healing capabilities

No PageCache Pollution Affects Write

AutoMQ uses cloud storage as WAL to ensure data persistence, and does not rely on Page Cache in its implementation, so it does not have the issue of Page Cache pollution like Kafka. Kafka, when reading cold data, will pollute the Page Cache, affecting write performance.

Separation of Cold and Hot Data

The read paths of AutoMQ's hot and cold data are completely isolated and do not affect each other. Consumers will read hot data directly from AutoMQ's Hot Data Cache. Cold data will be loaded from S3 to the cold data cache in memory using techniques such as prefetch and concurrency. Consumers reading historical data will read from the cold data cache and will not involve disk reads like Kafka.

No Intra-Cluster Partition Data Movement

The data persistence of AutoMQ has been delegated to cloud storage, which means that there is no need to use three replicas within the cluster like Kafka. Therefore, when writing data to the AutoMQ cluster, there is no need for cross-network synchronization of replica partition data within a cluster like Kafka. The network bandwidth of cloud vendor's computing instances is directly proportional to the instance specifications. Since there is no internal data replication, this means that AutoMQ does not need to occupy additional EC2 network bandwidth for data replication. Therefore, smaller computing instance specifications can be used to bear the same write throughput as Kafka.

Single-Digit Millisecond Publish Latency

Kafka leverages Page Cache in combination with multiple replicas (ISR) to provide powerful throughput and low latency. AutoMQ uses WAL to ensure persistence but can still have superior performance compared to Apache Kafka. The key lies in:
a. Using Direct I/O technology to bypass the file system to write to raw devices to improve performance.
b. Cloud block storage services like EBS have already provided extremely low write latency.
c. Kafka uses multiple replicas (ISR) to ensure data persistence, which requires additional network I/O overhead.
AutoMQ Enterprise
Apache Kafka
Details
Single-digit millisecond P99 write latency

Like Apache Kafka, AutoMQ also provides extremely low write latency through techniques such as Direct I/O and high-performance EBS WAL. See Benchmark for more details.

2x Max Throughput than Apache Kafka

AutoMQ offloads data persistence to cloud storage, and does not need to replicate partition data internally when writing data, so it can handle larger write throughput under the same compute instance specifications and network bandwidth.

Eliminate performance degradation issues caused by Page Cache pollution

Kafka generates a large amount of disk reads when reading historical data, polluting the Page Cache and leading to severe degradation of write performance. AutoMQ avoids this problem by using Direct I/O and high-performance EBS WAL instead of Page Cache.

More stable latency

AutoMQ is unaffected by PageCache pollution, leading to more stable latency performance with reduced jitter.

AutoMQ Enterprise
Apache Kafka
Details
Official IaC support

Apache Kafka is open-source software. Without official IaC support, it relies solely on the community. AutoMQ, on the other hand, provides enterprise-level IaC support, enabling users to fully manage AutoMQ using Terraform.

SaaS/BYOC support

As enterprise software, AutoMQ provides fully managed SaaS and BYOC modes, so there's no need to manage and operate clusters like Apache Kafka.

Compatibility with Kafka ecosystem tools

AutoMQ is fully compatible with Apache Kafka, so all ecosystem tools and products compatible with Apache Kafka can be used.

Data and partition self-balancing

AutoMQ features automatic data and partition balancing, allowing for hands-free ops. With Kafka, you need a 3rd party tool (Cruise Control) for partition and data balancing.

Metrics Integration

Build in Metrics Exporter, supports OTLP/Prometheus RemotWrite/CloudWatch/....

Hands-free scaling

AutoMQ's innovative storage architecture can complete cluster scaling in seconds, without the need to formulate partition migration strategies and data replication like Kafka.

Built-in automated upgrades

AutoMQ provides productized automated upgrade capabilities, eliminating the need for manual upgrades. Apache Kafka requires manual intervention.

AutoMQ Enterprise
Apache Kafka
Details
Stateless Broker can utilize Spot instances

AutoMQ's Broker is stateless, so it can use spot instances to replace on-demand instances to significantly save on the cost of compute instances.

All primary data is stored on pay-as-you-go object storage like S3

S3-compatible cloud storage is the default storage for all streaming data, allowing for near-infinite data retention at a low cost.

No-Overprovision (AutoScaling)

Scaling Apache Kafka is very difficult, requiring a large amount of computing and storage space to be reserved for peak loads. AutoMQ supports rapid automatic scaling, eliminating the need to reserve resources for peak loads, and can automatically scale up and down based on the load.

Easy Day 2 operations

AutoMQ automation and intelligent cluster handling eliminates the manual tuning associated with Apache Kafka.

AutoMQ Enterprise
Apache Kafka
Details
Self-healing, autonomous cluster

The self-balancing component built into AutoMQ continuously monitors the cluster status, helping the cluster to self-heal from abnormal scenarios such as uneven traffic, data hotspots, and compute instance crashes. Apache Kafka requires manual handling of the above anomalies.

Durability

AutoMQ fully adheres to the cloud-first design philosophy, offloading data persistence to cloud storage, which can provide up to 99.999999999% data durability. Apache Kafka uses ISR for replication, which can be subject to unsafe leader election and data loss.

Cold reads do not affect cluster throughput

During cold reads, Apache Kafka reads from the disk, polluting the Page Cache, which quickly degrades the cluster's write performance, severely affecting the stability of the production system.

7*24 Business Support

AutoMQ customers can enjoy 24*7 official cluster hosting and monitoring services. AutoMQ experts will monitor the security and stability of your production cluster 24*7. Apache Kafka “support” is 100% community driven.

Start Your AutoMQ Journey Today

Contact us to schedule an online meeting to learn more, request PoC assistance, or arrange a demo.
扫码加微信咨询